Home sellers looking for a home upgrade that can have an aesthetic impact and be financially smart might start with the front door. Replacing a worn front door isn’t just a cosmetic fix—it’s one of the best remodeling projects for return on investment, according to the 2025 Remodeling Impact Report from the National Association of REALTORS® and the National Association of the Remodeling Industry.
Agents who are REALTORS® estimate a new steel front door could offer a 100% cost recovery at resale, while a fiberglass front door could bring back around 80% of its cost. That makes it one of the rare updates that may pay for itself entirely when it comes time to sell. Of course, the cost recovery on any remodel or upgrade depends on an array of factors, including buyer expectations and the condition of comparable properties in the neighborhood.
Why the Front Door Matters
When a home is on the market, the front door is one of the first things people notice. It’s usually featured in online photos and sets the tone for the house, framing the entryway and playing a major role in curb appeal.
Real estate experts agree: A clean, updated and stylish front door can make a home feel more welcoming and well-maintained.
The Door Colors That Sell
According to a report from Fixr.com, which surveyed professionals in the window and door industry, wood-grain doors are tops. The pros say that wood-grain doors are the trendiest option partially because of the growing desire for biophilic design, combining the outdoors with the indoors. Also a trendy option: Black front doors. Pros surveyed by Fixr.com said a black door can complement a variety of siding and exterior colors in enhancing a home’s curb appeal.
Steel vs. Fiberglass: Which One Should You Choose?
- Steel doors tend to be more affordable and secure, and they’re often chosen for their clean, modern look. They’re also what delivers the highest cost recovery, according to NAR’s Remodeling Impact Report.
- Fiberglass doors, while slightly pricier, offer durability, energy efficiency and a more customizable appearance—often mimicking the look of real wood with less maintenance.
Either material can dramatically update the home's exterior and improve insulation, security and resale potential.
Homeowners with an eye toward a sale: If your front door is outdated, worn or just lacking character, a simple replacement could be one of the most effective and profitable upgrades you make this year.
