When a judge dismissed a Florida broker's case against the National Association of REALTORS®, local REALTOR® associations and multiple listing services in April after the broker failed to show an antitrust agreement to restrain trade had taken place, the judge gave him another chance to prove his point.
On Monday, that opportunity closed in district court after the judge tossed the broker's amended complaint for the same reason.
The district judge agreed with a magistrate judge's October recommendation to throw out the case, this time, with prejudice.
"To state a claim under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, it is not enough to allege conclusorily that certain actions resulted from a conspiracy; the plaintiff must allege facts that make the existence of an agreement plausible. Plaintiff has not done so here," wrote U.S. Magistrate Judge Shaniek Mills Maynard in a 23-page report.
The lawsuit, first filed in August 2025, centered around broker Jorge Zea who operates a low-cost, limited-service listing platform called SnapFlatFee.com. He sued NAR, eight local Florida REALTOR® associations and five MLSs, alleging a concerted effort not to enforce commission steering, buyer-broker written agreements, the MLS non-filtering rule and more. In his amended complaint, Zea claimed that NAR and the codefendants conspired to suppress his business model and “any market participant who deviates from the traditional full-service commission model.”
A spokesperson for NAR said they were pleased with the judge's decision.
"As we have previously stated, the National Association of REALTORS® fosters a fair, transparent, and competitive real estate marketplace," a statement reads. "Steering is a prohibited practice under NAR policy and the REALTOR® Code of Ethics. The Code of Ethics is enforced by state and local REALTOR® associations, and the enforcement of MLS rules are handled by each MLS."
This development follows a string of successful legal momentum including three recent appellate court dismissals in the Muhammad, Eytalis and Homie cases.









