Did Someone Say Sinkhole?

Courtesy of:
Victor Insurance Managers Inc.
Two Wisconsin Circle
Chevy Chase, MD 20815-7022
Phone: 301-961-9800
Fax: 301-951-5444

Download the PDF

The Facts

Ms. Lee, a real estate agent with Flashlight Realty, listed Mr. Robertson’s property for sale. During the process, Mr. Robertson did not submit any material facts to be disclosed to a buyer. However, a month after the property was listed, Ms. Lee received a phone call from a man claiming to be the next door neighbor of Mr. Robertson. The neighbor claimed there was a sinkhole on the property and the previous year he filed a claim with his insurer but it was denied because it was said to be “normal settlement.” Ms. Lee asked the neighbor to provide her with a copy of the claim and sinkhole determination, but he did not follow through. When approached about this issue, Mr. Robertson said that no one ever mentioned a sinkhole. Mr. Robertson filled out the disclosure form in good faith and said he never had any settlement issues with the house.

Risk Factor #1

Ms. Lee should have disclosed the information she received from the neighbor. Facts that materially affect the value of the property which are not known or are not discoverable upon reasonable investigation by the buyer need to be reported. Even an anonymous phone call should have been investigated and disclosed.

A couple of months after the property was listed an offer was made by the Adams’. The offer was accepted and then the home was inspected. Ms. Lee was not present during the home inspection.

Risk Factor #2

Ms. Lee should have been present during the home inspection or at least obtained a copy of the inspection report for her documents.
No problems were reported after the inspection and Mr. Robertson and the Adams’ proceeded to close on the property.

After moving into the property, the Adams’ discovered cracks in the walls and ceilings which had been concealed by paint and crown molding. They also claimed to have learned about the sinkhole on the neighboring property, including a grout hole just eight feet from one of the bedroom windows of their house.

The Adams’ found out that Ms. Lee was made aware of the sinkhole before the final sale. Ms. Lee explained that she received an anonymous call from the neighbor but never received documentation of the claim. However, the Adams’ stated their neighbor gave them a copy of the sinkhole report.

The Result

The Adams’ sued Flashlight Realty for failure to disclose known issues with the property. The Adams’ won the case and were awarded damages plus fees and costs. The case was settled for $200,000 in damages.

Any examples in this article are for illustrative purposes only and any similarity to actual individuals, entities, places or situations is unintentional and purely coincidental. This material is not intended to establish any standards of care or to serve as legal advice appropriate for any particular factual situations. Please remember that only the relevant insurance policy can provide the actual terms, coverages, amounts, conditions and exclusions for an insured.

Copyright © 2011 Victor Insurance Managers Inc. All rights reserved.

These articles are not the product of the National Association of REALTORS®, and may not reflect NAR's viewpoint or position on these topics and NAR does not verify the accuracy of the content.



Find the information, education, and connections you need to thrive in the growing field of international real estate.

Voice for Real Estate: January 6, 2020

Get takeaways from NAR's first-ever Real Estate Forecast Summit and annual conference; learn about key federal budget wins for real estate; and more.